lighthouse counsel logo
Reading the Financials: A Practical Guide for Board Members

Reading the Financials: A Practical Guide for Board Members

October 5, 2026
Joe Chickey

I came into philanthropy through finance. I hold a degree in finance and an MBA, and I spent 15 years as a bank trust officer working with nonprofit endowments, family foundations and more than 125 charities across the Southeast. I have also spent a career on the other side, raising major and planned gifts and helping lead campaigns of $1.5 billion and $500 million.

That mix left me with a habit I recommend to every board member: Read the financial statements the way a lender reads them and then read them again the way a donor should.

Board members are asked to accept the audit, approve the budget and exercise financial oversight. Many arrive with no training in any of it. In my experience, the most common failure in a finance committee meeting is not a bad number – it is silence. Everyone assumes someone else understands the packet, and the motion carries.

You do not need an accounting degree to be useful in that room. You need to know where to look, what a good answer sounds like and which questions are always fair to ask.

The four statements and what each one answers

An audited financial statement contains four pieces, and each answers a different question.

  • The statement of financial position, which many people still call the balance sheet, answers what the organization owns and what it owes on one specific day.
  • The statement of activities, effectively the income statement, answers what came in and what went out over the year, and what that did to net assets.
  • The statement of functional expenses answers how we spent it, sorted both by nature (such as salaries and rent) and by function (such as program, management and general and fundraising).
  • The statement of cash flows answers whether cash actually moved. An organization can post a surplus and still be unable to make payroll.

Since the Financial Accounting Standards Board’s 2016-14 update, nonprofits report net assets in two classes rather than three: net assets without donor restrictions and net assets with donor restrictions. The same standard requires every nonprofit to present the functional expense analysis and, importantly, to disclose both quantitatively and qualitatively the financial assets available to meet general expenditures within one year of the balance sheet date.

That liquidity disclosure is the single most useful paragraph in most nonprofit audits – and most board members never find it.

The number nobody puts on the cover page

Total net assets tell you very little on their own. A school can report $40 million in net assets and still struggle to make payroll in February because the money is in buildings and donor-restricted endowment.

Sort net assets into three practical buckets:

  • Truly available. Unrestricted and unencumbered. This is what funds operations.
  • Board designated. Sitting inside net assets without donor restrictions, this is money the board set aside and can release.
  • Donor restricted. Purpose-restricted or endowed. This is not yours to redirect.

Then take the available figure, cross-check it against the liquidity note and divide by average monthly operating expenses. That gives you months of operating reserve.

The Nonprofit Operating Reserves Initiative Workgroup has long recommended a minimum of 25% of the annual operating expense budget, roughly three months, with many organizations targeting six once the first three are secure. The National Council of Nonprofits notes that many nonprofits report holding less than three months. Knowing your own number, and its direction over three years, is basic fiduciary literacy.

Ten steps for your next finance committee meeting

1. Read the opinion first. It is on the first page, and it is short. An unmodified, or clean, opinion is what you want. Any other language, particularly a going concern paragraph, belongs at the top of the agenda rather than buried in it.

2. Read the footnotes second. The statements tell you what happened. The notes tell you why. Start with significant accounting policies, liquidity and availability, net asset composition, endowment, debt and commitments and contingencies.

3. Convert liquidity into months. Find the availability disclosure, divide by average monthly expenses, and track the result over time. One figure is a snapshot. Three years is a trend.

4. Separate operating from non-operating results. Bequests, unrealized investment gains and multi-year grants recognized in full can make a difficult year look excellent. Ask management to present the operating result on its own line.

5. Look at revenue concentration. If a single grant, contract, event or donor exceeds a fifth of revenue, that is not merely a fundraising challenge – it is a strategic risk sitting on your balance sheet.

6. Age the contributions receivable. Pledges are recorded as revenue when promised, not when paid. Look for the allowance for uncollectible pledges and the present value discount, then ask how the allowance was estimated and how it has performed historically.

7. Read the functional expense statement for method, not just ratios. The allocation basis, usually time studies or square footage, tells you more than the resulting percentages do. Be wary of ratio-driven decisions. An organization that starves its accounting, technology and fundraising to protect a percentage is not being efficient. It is deferring a bill.

8. Compare budget to actual and then to forecast. A variance report against a stale budget in month nine tells you very little. Ask for a rolling forecast that reflects what leadership now believes will happen.

9. Read the management letter and track remediation. Auditors report control deficiencies separately from the opinion. Significant deficiencies and material weaknesses should each have an owner and a date, and the list should get shorter each year.

10. Meet the auditor in executive session, without management present, once a year. Two questions are always appropriate: Were there any disagreements with management, and were there adjustments you proposed that were not recorded?

Your Form 990 is a different document

The Form 990 is not your audit. It is a public information return, and it is written for a different audience. Part VI asks about governance practices, including whether your governing body received a copy of the form before it was filed. Part IX presents functional expenses. Schedule A documents the public support test that protects your public charity status. Schedule J covers compensation.

Numbers will not match your audit exactly, and that is normal because the two documents follow different reporting conventions. What is not acceptable is a board that has never read the form. Donors, grant makers, watchdog organizations and reporters all read it, and it is frequently the first document a prospective major donor sees.

A closing thought

Financial oversight is not about “catching” someone. It is about making sure the organization can keep its promises. Every donor-restricted line on that balance sheet represents a commitment somebody made to somebody else, sometimes decades ago. Reading the statements carefully is how a board honors those commitments, and asking a plain question in a quiet room is not a sign that you do not belong there. It is the job.

Lighthouse Counsel helps boards and executives strengthen financial oversight, board orientation and the governance practices that give donors confidence. If your board would benefit from a financial literacy session or a fresh look at how your financial information is presented, start a conversation with us at lighthousecounsel.com/contact/.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Avatar photo

Joe Chickey

Joe Chickey brings more than thirty years of advancement experience to his role as senior advisor, supporting clients across the full range of Lighthouse Counsel services including fundraising, strategic planning and board and leadership development. His background spans major gifts, legacy giving, campaigns and endowment growth, with proven success in helping mission-driven organizations secure transformative support. Joe is also widely respected for his expertise in gift planning, which he developed over fifteen years working with universities, independent schools, hospitals and environmental organizations.  For nearly a decade and a half, Joe served as the senior vice president and senior consultant at Sharpe Groupe, a Memphis, Tennessee–based nonprofit consulting firm. Previously, Joe served as a major and planned giving officer for both the University of Illinois Foundation, where he acted as the lead fundraiser for a $1.5 billion capital campaign, and at Rush University Medical Center in Chicago, where he spearheaded a $500 million capital campaign. He also worked as a philanthropic advisor for St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital. Throughout all of these roles, he administered charitable remainder trusts, lead trusts, gift annuities, life estates and IRA gifts.  Joe also spent fifteen years as a bank trust officer for various financial institutions, focusing on estate and financial planning, asset management and charitable planning for nonprofit endowments, family foundations and high-net-worth clients. While serving as a vice president and trust officer for Regions Morgan Keegan, he worked with more than 125 charities throughout the Southeastern United States as a leader in the Endowments and Foundations Group.  He lives in Asheville, North Carolina, but often travels widely for speaking engagements, sharing his insights on planned giving and other topics to estate planning councils, community foundations, AFP, CASE and CGP groups. He has spoken to the Chicago Council on Planned Giving and the National Capital Gift Planning Council as well as performed onsite training for Purdue University, the University of Texas System and the University of Oklahoma. Joe has also served as a board member of the National Association of Charitable Gift Planners and is a current member of the Leadership Institute.  Joe earned a bachelor’s degree in finance from Rhodes College and a master’s degree in business administration from the University of Illinois. Despite his vast experience in the field, his ethos on charitable giving remains simple, as evidenced by his favorite quote by Mahatma Gandhi: “Be the change you wish to see in the world.”